**Committee of Ten**
**Definition:**
The Committee of Ten was a group of educators and scholars convened in 1892 by the National Education Association in the United States to standardize and reform secondary education curricula. Its recommendations significantly influenced the structure and content of American high school education.
—
## Committee of Ten
The Committee of Ten was a pivotal educational commission formed in 1892 under the auspices of the National Education Association (NEA) in the United States. Comprised of ten prominent educators and scholars, the committee was tasked with reviewing and recommending a standardized curriculum for American secondary schools. Its work aimed to address inconsistencies in secondary education and to better prepare students for college and civic life. The committee’s recommendations had a lasting impact on the development of the American high school system and the broader educational landscape.
### Historical Context
In the late 19th century, the United States was experiencing rapid industrialization and social change, which brought new demands for an educated workforce and informed citizenry. Secondary education, however, was highly fragmented, with significant variation in curricula, teaching methods, and academic standards across different regions and schools. There was no consensus on what constituted an appropriate high school education, and many schools focused either on classical studies or vocational training without a unified framework.
The National Education Association, recognizing the need for reform, appointed the Committee of Ten in 1892 to examine the state of secondary education and propose recommendations for a more coherent and effective curriculum. The committee was chaired by Charles W. Eliot, then president of Harvard University, and included leading educators from various disciplines.
### Objectives and Composition
The primary objective of the Committee of Ten was to establish a standardized curriculum that would serve as a model for secondary schools nationwide. The committee sought to ensure that all students, regardless of their future plans, received a rigorous and comprehensive education. This included preparation for college as well as for practical life and citizenship.
The committee consisted of ten members, each an expert in a particular academic field or educational practice. Their expertise spanned the humanities, sciences, and pedagogy, allowing for a broad and balanced approach to curriculum design. The members were tasked with reviewing existing curricula, consulting with educators and institutions, and formulating recommendations that could be widely adopted.
### Key Recommendations
The Committee of Ten’s report, published in 1893, laid out several key recommendations that shaped secondary education for decades:
#### Uniform Curriculum
The committee advocated for a uniform curriculum for all students, regardless of whether they intended to pursue higher education. They argued that the same subjects should be taught to all students, with differences in depth and pace rather than content. This was a departure from the prevailing practice of tracking students into classical or vocational paths early in their education.
#### Subject Areas
The committee identified nine core subject areas that should be included in the secondary curriculum:
– Latin
– Greek
– English
– Mathematics
– History
– Science (including physics, chemistry, and biology)
– Modern languages (such as French and German)
– Geography
– Physical training
The inclusion of classical languages like Latin and Greek reflected the committee’s belief in the value of a classical education, while the emphasis on sciences and modern languages acknowledged the changing needs of society.
#### College Preparation
The committee emphasized that secondary education should prepare students for college-level work. They recommended that high schools align their curricula with college entrance requirements to facilitate a smoother transition to higher education. This alignment helped standardize admissions criteria and raised academic expectations.
#### Teaching Methods
The Committee of Ten also addressed pedagogical approaches, advocating for teaching methods that emphasized understanding and critical thinking rather than rote memorization. They encouraged the use of laboratory work in science education and the study of literature in English classes to develop analytical skills.
#### Length and Pace of Study
The committee recommended that the secondary education program span four years, with a consistent pace of study across subjects. They suggested that students who wished to study certain subjects more intensively could do so, but the overall curriculum should remain balanced.
### Impact on American Education
The Committee of Ten’s report had a profound and lasting influence on American secondary education. Its recommendations helped establish the high school as a key institution for preparing students for both college and citizenship. The idea of a common curriculum for all students became a foundational principle in American education policy.
#### Standardization and Curriculum Development
Following the committee’s report, many states and school districts adopted standardized curricula based on its recommendations. This contributed to greater uniformity in educational content and expectations across the country. The committee’s work also influenced the development of standardized testing and college entrance examinations.
#### Expansion of High School Education
The committee’s emphasis on a comprehensive curriculum helped promote the expansion of high schools and increased enrollment. As secondary education became more accessible and standardized, it played a larger role in social mobility and workforce development.
#### Criticism and Evolution
Despite its influence, the Committee of Ten’s recommendations were not without criticism. Some educators argued that the uniform curriculum was too rigid and did not adequately address the diverse needs and interests of students. The emphasis on classical languages was seen by some as outdated, especially as the United States became more industrialized and diverse.
Over time, educational reformers introduced more flexible curricula, vocational training, and differentiated instruction to better serve varied student populations. Nonetheless, the Committee of Ten’s work laid the groundwork for ongoing debates about curriculum design and educational standards.
### Legacy
The Committee of Ten is remembered as a landmark effort in the history of American education. Its report marked one of the first major attempts to create a national consensus on secondary education and to link high school curricula with college preparation. The committee’s vision of a rigorous, comprehensive education for all students influenced educational policy well into the 20th century.
While educational philosophies and practices have evolved since the 1890s, the Committee of Ten’s emphasis on academic rigor, standardized curricula, and the importance of secondary education remains relevant. Its work helped shape the modern American high school and continues to be studied by educators and historians interested in the development of education in the United States.
—
**Meta Description:**
The Committee of Ten was a group of educators in 1892 who standardized American secondary education curricula, influencing high school education and college preparation. Their recommendations shaped the development of the U.S. education system for decades.